Managing Basic Education MBE Project Online Supported by USAID
 


BAHASA INDONESIA

Ayo, let's support the Managing Basic Education Project

Candidates to be merged?
SD Kauman 3 and 4 are situated on the same site around the same small school yard. SD Kauman 4 has 175 students and SD Kauman 3 has 116 students. In grade 5 at SD Kauman 4 there are 28 students whereas grade 5 in SD Kauman 3 has only 14 students.

There is a complete staff of teachers in each of the schools, with the exception of the lack of a sports teacher in SD Kauman 3, while many of the other schools in Batang sub-district have shortages of teachers. Each of the schools has a collection of library books but no room to use as a library. The condition of a number of classrooms in SD Kauman 3 is already poor (with holes in the roofs). The two schools already have a single school committee.

Based on the analysis of the mapping data a merger of these two schools is being proposed. The children will be able to be spread more evenly across the classes if there are parallel classes. Where there are no parallel classes the excess teachers can be used at schools which are short of teachers. A classroom which is no longer used can be turned into a library. The classrooms which are in bad condition may possibly not need to be used any more.

SDN Kauman Sign Kep-Sek SDN Kauman 3-4 Kondisi Ruang Kelas

The school principals of SD Kauman 3 and 4. The schools are situated around one yard and the number of students has fallen. Some of the classrooms in SD 3 are in a very poor condition.

The “Art” of School Mergers
The experience of Tulakan sub-district, Pacitan: Regrouping the merging of (normally two) schools to become one seems a simple concept, but difficult to implement in practice.

The “Art” of School Mergers (continued)
The problems which normally arise include complaints from the community (parents), one of the school principals (who will lose his or her position), teachers (who have to move schools), etc. As a result, only a few schools are successfully merged, even though on paper more need to be merged.

SDN Losari 1 and SDN Losari 3 were two schools which technically could be merged. They were on the same site, sharing a school yard but have different numbers of students. SDN 1 had more pupils (approximately 125), while SDN 3 has few pupils (only about 75), and numbers are still falling. Bapak Sulistyo, the branch head of the Dinas Pendidikan in Tulakan sub-district bravely took the initiative to merge the schools during the 2000/2001 school year without waiting for an official letter from the Bupati, and was able to do it without causing any conflict. The steps he took included:

  • Explaining the merger plans to the two schools (teachers and parents), in particular the reasons for merging the schools.
  • Coordinating with other stakeholders (sub-district head, village head, head of public works – to assess the condition of the buildings);
  • Planning the career of the school principal who would lose his position;
  • Planning the redeployment of teachers to other schools.

For schools with small numbers of students which are situated well apart from each other (which makes it difficult to merge them) the schools can be changed from conventional primary schools (with 6 class teachers) to small primary schools (with 3 class teachers). Meanwhile for private schools the decision is left to the school management, but local government decides on a minimum number of students for schools to be eligible to receive certain kinds of assistance. With such mechanisms it is hoped that the essence of the school regrouping (improving the efficiency of education provision) can be carried out in various kinds of schools.

Making Efficient Use of Teachers
All areas complain of teacher shortages, whereas in fact in several areas the ratio of the number of students to teachers is fairly low. The basis of calculating the number of teachers needs to change. At present the number of class teachers in primary schools is calculated according to the number of grades (normally six). However few children there are for one grade (sometimes less than five students) schools still feel they need one teacher per grade. As a result there are some teacher teaching small numbers of students (often less than 15), while others have to teach more than 60.

Is there an alternative? In most countries teachers are allocated to schools based on the numbers of students, not on the number of grades. For example, in some parts of India teachers are allocated to schools on the basis of one teacher for every 40 students. Of course, this means that many teacher have to teach multi-grade classes – but this is not too difficult when teachers get used to it. If teachers were allocated to schools according to the number of students, perhaps there would be no shortage of teachers, and perhaps no classes without a teacher. Is any district brave enough to give it a try?


Does PAKEM Improve Student Performance?

A fear that is often expressed when in the field is that many schools are worried that implementing PAKEM may reduce examination scores. But in fact, it is hoped that PAKEM will result in more effective lessons, so that children are more skilful, and understand and can apply the concepts they learn.

As an example of the success in one school which has been implementing SBM and PAKEM, the children in class 1 are learning to read and write more quickly. By the middle of the first semester most of the students can already read and can write their own simple sentences. This has happened because they have been involving parents in helping in class and have been using more interesting teaching methods.

One problem which often occurs in old style teaching is that the children memorise a formula but are unable to use the formula in solving a problem. For example:

If the children in class 4 are asked to work out the area of rectangle A most can answer because they have memorised the formula: area = length x breadth. But if children are asked to work out the area of shape B most cannot answer correctly, because they do not really understand what area is and have not practiced solving problems, because they are always given the answers by the teacher!

Soal Luas
RTI INTERNATIONAL Managing Basic Education (MBE) USAID